Case dropped against Jewish activist charged over "bloody hands" protest for Palestine
Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods | 12.03.2009 10:08 | Palestine | Repression | World
Pro-Palestinian campaigners claimed victory on Wednesday when charges were dropped against a Jewish activist arrested for protesting at a celebration of Israel's 60th anniversary last June.
Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, 56, from Woodford Green, Essex, was due to appear at the City of London Magistratescourt on Thursday following her arrest at the Salute Israel parade through central Londonon 29 June 2008.
But with hours to go the Crown Prosecution Services told her solicitor it had decided to "discontinue these charges . . . because a prosecution is not needed in the public interest".
"This decision is welcome, of course, but it raises the question, why
was the case brought in the first place?" said Wimborne-Idrissi. "I
have taken legal advice and am now considering whether to bring legal
action against the police for wrongful arrest".
Her arrest occurred after she displayed the slogan "Palestinian blood on Israeli hands", and silently held up her hands dyed red with food
colouring as the pro-Israel parade passed down the Haymarket in central London.
"Within minutes I was attacked by three separate Israel supporters, one
of whom threatened to slit my throat," Wimborne-Idrissi said. "The
police should have defended my right to freedom of expression. Instead I was arrested and charged under Section 5 of the Public Order Act with 'causing harassment, alarm and distress'".
Solicitor Simon Natas, representing Wimborne-Idrissi, said his client's action had been "entirely peaceful and legitimate" . The arrest had undermined her right to free speech.
Daniel Machover, Chair of Lawyers for Palestinian Human Rights (LPHR),
commenting on the case last week, said legitimate protest should not
be criminalised.
"Given Israel's illegal occupation of Palestinian land and the
persistent brutality of the Israeli authorities towards Palestinians, as witnessed in Gaza just weeks ago, supporters of these policies cannot expect their celebrations or marches to be held without reasonable dissent", Machover said.
NOTES
1. The Salute Israel parade on 29 June 2008 was organised by the British Board of Jewish Deputies and the Zionist Federation, supported by the Israeli Embassy. It was a carnival-style event culminating in a political rally in Trafalgar Squarecelebrating the 60 years since Israel's foundation in 1948.
2. For almost 10 million Palestinians around the world, 70 percent of whom are refugees, the foundation of the State of Israel was a catastrophe they call the Nakba. At least 700,000 Paelstinians were driven from their homes.
3. In his book The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (One World, Oxford, 2006) Israeli historian Ilan Pappe documents the many killings of Palestinians during the year of the Nakba. He concludes (p.197): "Thousands of Palestinians were killed ruthlessly and savagely by Israeli troops of all backgrounds, ranks and ages. None of these Israelis was ever tried for war crimes, in spite of the overwhelming
evidence".
4. Ethnic cleansing continued sporadically from 1948, reaching a crescendo in 1967, when thousands of Palestinians were again driven out by Israeli forces. The Badil Resource Centre for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights records in its 2005 Survey (p.20-21):
"Refugee camps in Jericho, for example, were bombed by the Israeli air
force, leading to an exodus of tens of thousands of refugees. . . By the time the 1967 war came to an end 430,000 Palestinians were displaced, among them some 193,500 refugees displaced for a second time, and 240,000 residents displaced from the West Bankand Gaza Strip for the first time".
5. Israel has continued to kill, displace, humiliate and impoverish
Palestinians in the occupied West Bankand Gaza.In 2000, the US-based website www.rememberthesechildren.com began cataloguing all the deaths of Palestinian and Israeli children, from 0 to 17 years of age. Between September 2000 and the end of 2008, 1,056 Palestinian children were killed. In the same period 123 Israeli children were killed.
This precedes the slaughter which took place in Gaza in the three weeks starting 27 December 2008, taking a further 1,300 Palestinian lives, more than 200 of them children.
But with hours to go the Crown Prosecution Services told her solicitor it had decided to "discontinue these charges . . . because a prosecution is not needed in the public interest".
"This decision is welcome, of course, but it raises the question, why
was the case brought in the first place?" said Wimborne-Idrissi. "I
have taken legal advice and am now considering whether to bring legal
action against the police for wrongful arrest".
Her arrest occurred after she displayed the slogan "Palestinian blood on Israeli hands", and silently held up her hands dyed red with food
colouring as the pro-Israel parade passed down the Haymarket in central London.
"Within minutes I was attacked by three separate Israel supporters, one
of whom threatened to slit my throat," Wimborne-Idrissi said. "The
police should have defended my right to freedom of expression. Instead I was arrested and charged under Section 5 of the Public Order Act with 'causing harassment, alarm and distress'".
Solicitor Simon Natas, representing Wimborne-Idrissi, said his client's action had been "entirely peaceful and legitimate" . The arrest had undermined her right to free speech.
Daniel Machover, Chair of Lawyers for Palestinian Human Rights (LPHR),
commenting on the case last week, said legitimate protest should not
be criminalised.
"Given Israel's illegal occupation of Palestinian land and the
persistent brutality of the Israeli authorities towards Palestinians, as witnessed in Gaza just weeks ago, supporters of these policies cannot expect their celebrations or marches to be held without reasonable dissent", Machover said.
NOTES
1. The Salute Israel parade on 29 June 2008 was organised by the British Board of Jewish Deputies and the Zionist Federation, supported by the Israeli Embassy. It was a carnival-style event culminating in a political rally in Trafalgar Squarecelebrating the 60 years since Israel's foundation in 1948.
2. For almost 10 million Palestinians around the world, 70 percent of whom are refugees, the foundation of the State of Israel was a catastrophe they call the Nakba. At least 700,000 Paelstinians were driven from their homes.
3. In his book The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (One World, Oxford, 2006) Israeli historian Ilan Pappe documents the many killings of Palestinians during the year of the Nakba. He concludes (p.197): "Thousands of Palestinians were killed ruthlessly and savagely by Israeli troops of all backgrounds, ranks and ages. None of these Israelis was ever tried for war crimes, in spite of the overwhelming
evidence".
4. Ethnic cleansing continued sporadically from 1948, reaching a crescendo in 1967, when thousands of Palestinians were again driven out by Israeli forces. The Badil Resource Centre for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights records in its 2005 Survey (p.20-21):
"Refugee camps in Jericho, for example, were bombed by the Israeli air
force, leading to an exodus of tens of thousands of refugees. . . By the time the 1967 war came to an end 430,000 Palestinians were displaced, among them some 193,500 refugees displaced for a second time, and 240,000 residents displaced from the West Bankand Gaza Strip for the first time".
5. Israel has continued to kill, displace, humiliate and impoverish
Palestinians in the occupied West Bankand Gaza.In 2000, the US-based website www.rememberthesechildren.com began cataloguing all the deaths of Palestinian and Israeli children, from 0 to 17 years of age. Between September 2000 and the end of 2008, 1,056 Palestinian children were killed. In the same period 123 Israeli children were killed.
This precedes the slaughter which took place in Gaza in the three weeks starting 27 December 2008, taking a further 1,300 Palestinian lives, more than 200 of them children.
Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods
Additions
Call out posted before case was dropped
12.03.2009 10:41
Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, 56, was arrested on 29 June 2008 at a pro-Israeli parade through central London. Wearing a T-shirt bearing the slogan, “Palestinian blood on Israeli hands,” she stood on the pavement as the parade moved along the Haymarket, holding up her hands dyed red with food colouring.
Killing is a crime - Dyeing is not : Defend the right to speak out for Palestine
Join our protest
Killing is a crime - Dyeing is not : Defend the right to speak out for Palestine
Join our protest
2 p.m. Thursday March 12 at the City of London Magistrates Court
1 Queen Victoria Street, London, EC4N 4XY
Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, 56, was arrested on 29 June 2008 at a pro-Israeli parade through central London. Wearing a T-shirt bearing the slogan, “Palestinian blood on Israeli hands,” she stood on the pavement as the parade moved along the Haymarket, holding up her hands dyed red with food colouring.
Within minutes she was attacked by three separate Israel supporters, one of whom threatened to slit her throat. She was arrested without explanation, searched and prevented from speaking to anyone other than the police. She was held for four hours in a cell at Charing Cross police station, photographed, finger-printed and DNA tested. Eventually she was charged with “causing harassment, alarm and distress.”
“This would have been laughable if it were not such as serious breach of a citizen’s right to free speech,” she said. “The people on the parade were celebrating 60 years of an Israeli state which is responsible for thousands of Palestinian deaths and persists in denying Palestinians the most basic human rights. Since our government fails to call Israel to account for its repeated breaches of international law, including its illegal occupation of Palestinian land conquered in 1967, I felt morally obliged to expose the truth. It cannot be right for the law to prevent this and I will be contesting the charge.”
___________________
http://socialistresistance.org/?p=383
Jewish Activist On Trial Over “Bloody Hands” Protest For Palestine
Socialist Resistance, 10 March 2009
Pro-Palestinian campaigners with hands dyed blood red will gather at the City of London Magistrates Court on March 12th in support of a Jewish activist arrested for protesting at a celebration of Israel’s 60th anniversary last June. For almost 10 million Palestinians around the world, 70 percent of whom are refugees, the foundation of the State of Israel was a catastrophe they call the Nakba. At least 700,000 Palestinians were driven from their homes.
Representatives of several campaign groups will be monitoring proceedings when Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi from Woodford Green, Essex, contests her arrest at the Salute Israel parade through central London on 29 June 2008.
The Salute Israel parade on 29 June 2008 was organised by the British Board of Jewish Deputies and the Zionist Federation, supported by the Israeli Embassy. It was a carnival-style event culminating in a political rally in Trafalgar Square celebrating the 60 years since Israel’s foundation in 1948. As the parade passed down Haymarket she displayed the slogan “Palestinian blood on Israeli hands,” and silently held up her hands dyed red with food colouring.
In his book The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (One World, Oxford, 2006) Israeli historian Ilan Pappe documents the many killings of Palestinians during the year of the Nakba. He concludes (p.197): “Thousands of Palestinians were killed ruthlessly and savagely by Israeli troops of all backgrounds, ranks and ages. None of these Israelis was ever tried for war crimes, in spite of the overwhelming evidence.” Ethnic cleansing continued sporadically from 1948, reaching a crescendo in 1967, when thousands of Palestinians were again driven out by Israeli forces.
The Badil Resource Centre for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights records in its 2005 Survey (p.20-21): “Refugee camps in Jericho, for example, were bombed by the Israeli air force, leading to an exodus of tens of thousands of refugees. . . By the time the 1967 war came to an end 430,000 Palestinians were displaced, among them some 193,500 refugees displaced for a second time, and 240,000 residents displaced from the West Bank and Gaza Strip for the first time.”
Wimborne-Idriss explains that her action was conducted in the face of violent opposition” “Within minutes I was attacked by three separate Israel supporters, one of whom threatened to slit my throat. The police should have defended my right to freedom of expression. Instead I was arrested and charged under Section 5 of the Public Order Act with ‘causing harassment, alarm and distress’.”
Solicitor Simon Natas, representing Wimborne-Idrissi, said his client’s action had been “entirely peaceful and legitimate”.
“Her protest was intended to draw attention to the State of Israel’s abuses of Palestinian human rights,” he said. “We believe that this is a misguided prosecution that undermines the right to free speech and we will vigorously contest the charges.”
Daniel Machover, Chair of Lawyers for Palestinian Human Rights (LPHR), said he was concerned that a legitimate protest may be being criminalised.
“Given Israel’s illegal occupation of Palestinian land and the persistent brutality of the Israeli authorities towards Palestinians, as witnessed in Gaza just weeks ago, supporters of these policies cannot expect their celebrations or marches to be held without reasonable dissent,” Machover said.
Organisations represented at the proceedings on Thursday will include Jews for Justice for Palestinians, the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, the British Committee for the Universities of Palestine, the International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network, Legal Action for Women and Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods, of which Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi is a founder member.
Protest starts 1.30 p.m.
Thursday March 12
City of London Magistrates Court
1 Queen Victoria Street
London EC4N 4XY
(Bank underground station)
CONTACT
PO Box 64002, London, E17 0HD
Jews4BIG@googlemail.co.uk www.bigcampaign.org
Killing is a crime - Dyeing is not : Defend the right to speak out for Palestine
Join our protest
Killing is a crime - Dyeing is not : Defend the right to speak out for Palestine
Join our protest
2 p.m. Thursday March 12 at the City of London Magistrates Court
1 Queen Victoria Street, London, EC4N 4XY
Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, 56, was arrested on 29 June 2008 at a pro-Israeli parade through central London. Wearing a T-shirt bearing the slogan, “Palestinian blood on Israeli hands,” she stood on the pavement as the parade moved along the Haymarket, holding up her hands dyed red with food colouring.
Within minutes she was attacked by three separate Israel supporters, one of whom threatened to slit her throat. She was arrested without explanation, searched and prevented from speaking to anyone other than the police. She was held for four hours in a cell at Charing Cross police station, photographed, finger-printed and DNA tested. Eventually she was charged with “causing harassment, alarm and distress.”
“This would have been laughable if it were not such as serious breach of a citizen’s right to free speech,” she said. “The people on the parade were celebrating 60 years of an Israeli state which is responsible for thousands of Palestinian deaths and persists in denying Palestinians the most basic human rights. Since our government fails to call Israel to account for its repeated breaches of international law, including its illegal occupation of Palestinian land conquered in 1967, I felt morally obliged to expose the truth. It cannot be right for the law to prevent this and I will be contesting the charge.”
___________________
http://socialistresistance.org/?p=383 Jewish Activist On Trial Over “Bloody Hands” Protest For Palestine
Socialist Resistance, 10 March 2009
Pro-Palestinian campaigners with hands dyed blood red will gather at the City of London Magistrates Court on March 12th in support of a Jewish activist arrested for protesting at a celebration of Israel’s 60th anniversary last June. For almost 10 million Palestinians around the world, 70 percent of whom are refugees, the foundation of the State of Israel was a catastrophe they call the Nakba. At least 700,000 Palestinians were driven from their homes.
Representatives of several campaign groups will be monitoring proceedings when Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi from Woodford Green, Essex, contests her arrest at the Salute Israel parade through central London on 29 June 2008.
The Salute Israel parade on 29 June 2008 was organised by the British Board of Jewish Deputies and the Zionist Federation, supported by the Israeli Embassy. It was a carnival-style event culminating in a political rally in Trafalgar Square celebrating the 60 years since Israel’s foundation in 1948. As the parade passed down Haymarket she displayed the slogan “Palestinian blood on Israeli hands,” and silently held up her hands dyed red with food colouring.
In his book The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (One World, Oxford, 2006) Israeli historian Ilan Pappe documents the many killings of Palestinians during the year of the Nakba. He concludes (p.197): “Thousands of Palestinians were killed ruthlessly and savagely by Israeli troops of all backgrounds, ranks and ages. None of these Israelis was ever tried for war crimes, in spite of the overwhelming evidence.” Ethnic cleansing continued sporadically from 1948, reaching a crescendo in 1967, when thousands of Palestinians were again driven out by Israeli forces.
The Badil Resource Centre for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights records in its 2005 Survey (p.20-21): “Refugee camps in Jericho, for example, were bombed by the Israeli air force, leading to an exodus of tens of thousands of refugees. . . By the time the 1967 war came to an end 430,000 Palestinians were displaced, among them some 193,500 refugees displaced for a second time, and 240,000 residents displaced from the West Bank and Gaza Strip for the first time.”
Wimborne-Idriss explains that her action was conducted in the face of violent opposition” “Within minutes I was attacked by three separate Israel supporters, one of whom threatened to slit my throat. The police should have defended my right to freedom of expression. Instead I was arrested and charged under Section 5 of the Public Order Act with ‘causing harassment, alarm and distress’.”
Solicitor Simon Natas, representing Wimborne-Idrissi, said his client’s action had been “entirely peaceful and legitimate”.
“Her protest was intended to draw attention to the State of Israel’s abuses of Palestinian human rights,” he said. “We believe that this is a misguided prosecution that undermines the right to free speech and we will vigorously contest the charges.”
Daniel Machover, Chair of Lawyers for Palestinian Human Rights (LPHR), said he was concerned that a legitimate protest may be being criminalised.
“Given Israel’s illegal occupation of Palestinian land and the persistent brutality of the Israeli authorities towards Palestinians, as witnessed in Gaza just weeks ago, supporters of these policies cannot expect their celebrations or marches to be held without reasonable dissent,” Machover said.
Organisations represented at the proceedings on Thursday will include Jews for Justice for Palestinians, the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, the British Committee for the Universities of Palestine, the International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network, Legal Action for Women and Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods, of which Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi is a founder member.
Protest starts 1.30 p.m.
Thursday March 12
City of London Magistrates Court
1 Queen Victoria Street
London EC4N 4XY
(Bank underground station)
CONTACT
PO Box 64002, London, E17 0HD
Jews4BIG@googlemail.co.uk www.bigcampaign.org
reposter
