Skip navigation

Indymedia UK is a network of individuals, independent and alternative media activists and organisations, offering grassroots, non-corporate, non-commercial coverage of important social and political issues

Birmingham For The Alternative, TUC, Right to Work Demo,18th September

Stalingrad O'Neill | 21.09.2011 04:19 | Public sector cuts | Social Struggles | Workers' Movements | Birmingham

TUC Still throwing Labour a lifeline

Billy Hayes CWU
Billy Hayes CWU

Bombardier banner head of demo (1)
Bombardier banner head of demo (1)

Bombardier banner head of demo (2)
Bombardier banner head of demo (2)

Bombardier worker speaking on platform
Bombardier worker speaking on platform

UNISON Care Workers on Demo
UNISON Care Workers on Demo

Christine Blower NUT
Christine Blower NUT

Demonstrator Colemore Row
Demonstrator Colemore Row

Eleanor Lisney DPAC
Eleanor Lisney DPAC

Frances O'Grady TUC Deputy General Secretary,
Frances O'Grady TUC Deputy General Secretary,

Lancaster Street Rally
Lancaster Street Rally

Mark Serwotka PCS
Mark Serwotka PCS

Mary Bousted ATL General Secretary
Mary Bousted ATL General Secretary

Demo on Newhall Street
Demo on Newhall Street

Police Roadblock Convention Centre
Police Roadblock Convention Centre

Demonstrators
Demonstrators

Remploy demonstrator at rally
Remploy demonstrator at rally

SWAT Cops at Convention Centre
SWAT Cops at Convention Centre

Union Banners
Union Banners

UNISON Birmingham Branch Banner
UNISON Birmingham Branch Banner

Burslem Trent Valley Workers on march
Burslem Trent Valley Workers on march


The speakers from the platform certainly gave a good performance in reflecting the breadth of anger and resistance that exists in society, but what they failed to do was state, Labour, along with the other shower of Parliamentary fucks ain’t worth a pot to piss in

Mary Bousted from the ATL said that the unequal distribution of wealth means kids come to school anxious because parents fear losing job. Stating that November 30 will be biggest strike for generations – we have to fight to win the ballots”
Well Mary you got your work cut out if the attendance Sunday’s march is an indication of the present TUC leaderships ability to agitate and organize resistance The TUC’s 2,500 body count counterclaim, against the Police’s crowd estimate of 1,500 people joining the march along Broad Street says it all!

How anyone could stand on the platform and spout “What a splendid turn out”? Frances O'Grady you need a new pair of glasses, hang your head in shame, go back to TUC headquarters and kick the arse of yourself and everyone else involved. All this march showed was the utter inability or unwillingness of the TUC leadership to roll up their sleeves and get down to it. Fuck the bollocks of saving yourselves for the ‘Big One’!..... ‘The Tory Conference’ in October, as was made mention to me!
What is it a Day trip to Claxton coz it were no showcase highlighting any determined effort to prosecute the ongoing struggle for union members, wages, jobs, and public services?
If the ‘Big One’ is the sum total of perceived strategy to fight and confront the grinding continuation of cutting your members living standards, then you should not be in the job, for despite the spout of civil disobedience from the platform, the TUC seems to be impotent and an impediment to any such future effort

Case in point: Unite’s *Bombardier petition! Nothing wrong with that as part of a game plan but as with much else, it seems to be the be all and end all, with the TUC squatting its well rounded posterior on the side lines as usual, maybe, condescendingly allowing its offices for the organizing of a demonstration or two after the coup de grâce has been administered. It’s not rocket science knowing what needs to be done but either the TUC is afraid of its shite or it is conniving with those ‘Born to it’ to stymie its own members struggles

PCS Mark Serwotka a most left wing sounding of Union leader castigated Ed Miliband by ripping into Miliband’s TUC speech which condemned Union strike strategy against the cuts. However the continued inability of Union leaders to categorically break with Labour was unmistakably exposed when he added Milibucks “should side with workers fighting back! If he did that Labour would win by a landslide, we hope he thinks again” Whats the chances of that Mark? You think Milibucks is gonna miraculously be some Johnny Come Lately to “Fight every cut! Defend every job! Free education! Tax the rich!” ‘me arse he is!

I feel sorry for those trade unionists who attended in the hope that this would be the day the buck stops and their leaders would do what they are supposed to….. Fight and organize resistance by all means necessary to foil every government cut!
Unfortunately they found their efforts were thinly rewarded with a few rousing speeches pointing mainly to the “Fairy fellows master stroke” ….the choreographed November strike, Pish!

*Bombardier
Following the decision by the government to award the Thameslink contract to Siemens, and the subsequent decision by Bombardier to annuonce 1,400 redundancies,
Petition
"Keep UK Rail Manufacturing on track". Please sign the petition and forward to everyone you know:  http://www.unitetheunion.org/campaigns/keep_uk_rail_manufacturing_on.aspx

photos copyright Stalingrad O'Neill - permission is required for third party usage

Stalingrad O'Neill
- e-mail: robograd@tiscali.co.uk
- Homepage: http://stalingrad-oneill.photoshelter.com/


Comments

Hide the following 2 comments

Partially spurious criticism

21.09.2011 09:10

It would always be good if MORE people turned up to any protest, but I'd be more sympathetic to whining about numbers if the TUC's critics had a march of their own which they could definitely say drew more than (in this case) 1,500. It's easy to say the TUC aren't doing well enough but at least the TUC are doing SOMETHING, and until you've got a viable alternative to replace that with I suggest the tone of your criticism should reflect that reality.

Whatever the situation, this movement needs to take people who are sympathetic and involved already and keep them involved, so in that sense the march is a de-facto success, and unnecessarily defeatist critique can be counterproductive. The answer to the problem of numbers is for YOU personally to organise your own bulk e-mail-outs, press and poster campaigns and leafletting to make sure such demos are well attended, not to wait around for the TUC to wave their magic wand.

Truth is the march barely registered a blip in the mainstream media. UK Uncut did a banner drop which, likewise, attracted zero publicity, until 3 activists got arrested and then it made national news! In other words 3 people committing minor offences is more newsworthy than 1,500 ordinary, decent people marching about very serious issues. The media ignore legitimate protest and then get all indignant when protests get more militant as a result of being ignored.

We need PR stunts that attract media attention and get the message out to non-political people (without going so far as be portrayed as the crazed nutters The Daily Mail would love us to be), ie - non-violent direct action, and we need individual activists to take responsibility for the success or failure of protests they attend rather than indulging in "blame culture" as regards other people's perceived shortcomings. If you don't like it, do it better, yourself.

Practical anarchist


Police Guns and Activist Strategy

21.09.2011 09:31

The guns say it all - the Lib Dems are ready to kill protestors to stop them getting into the conference. As for the demo, alot of this looks like Trades Union / lefty groups preaching to the converted, that's not a criticism as such as it was a good protest but we need to pro-actively engage the GENERAL public.

The BNP published a book called "How It Was Done" describing how activist Steve Smith built up the Burnley branch into an organisation with 1,000 paid-up members, and there is no left-wing group in the world that wouldn't kill for a membership like that in a town like Burnley...

Basically (pre-internet days I think) his technique was to go through the Yellow Pages noting details of people he thought would be the BNP's natural constituency - white working-class people who are not represented by the Trades Unions, ie - self-employed sole traders like plumbers and electricians etc, and phone them ALL. Hey presto, biggest BNP branch in the country.

It's all gone tits up for the BNP since then but there's alot we can learn from this. Get online, get contact info for local people and media etc by any means necessary, and usurp the traditional (and very successful) right-wing populist argument by telling them the government is stealing entitlements that British taxpayers have been paying-in to for generations. We need creative thinking here not traditional leftism.

Mark One


Links