Skip navigation

Indymedia UK is a network of individuals, independent and alternative media activists and organisations, offering grassroots, non-corporate, non-commercial coverage of important social and political issues

Indymedia - growing pains or symptoms of decay

Pedro Heill | 08.10.2005 14:52 | G8 2005 | Analysis | Health | Indymedia | Sheffield

Over the last couple of weeks a battle has been raging and opening fissures that threaten to drive apart the United Kollectives of Indymedia on this island. Unless you subscribe to the Sheffield IMC mailing list you are likely to be unaware about the arguments over claims of lack of communication, transparency and the existence of hidden hierarchies within the network.

You'd be well advised to don a flame retardant suit if you subscribe to the email list of your local collective. A heated battle is raging, stoking the flames of discontent within the hallowed virtual halls of Indymedia.

At the core of the issue is the great satan, money. The conflict stems from debts incurred by IMC UK during coverage of the G8 summit in Scotland this July. With three seperate Indymedia centres, broadband provision, satellite truck, photodesk, video suite and radio studio, the total cost ammounted to somewhere in the region of 5,000 pounds.

Good value some say but others have claimed that they weren't consulted and question why their local collective should have to pick up the tab. The ensuing flame-fest has raised serious questions about communication and accountability within the network. As the accusations fly the question is whether the network will come out stronger as a result of the painful soul searching or will it be permanently wounded and hasten the call for increased or total autonomy occasionally heard from some of the regions.

The global network is not immune to these battles and bares the scares for all to see. Brisbane Indymedia was killed out of the network in late last year over apparent failure to uphold the principles of unity of the Indymedia Network.  http://docs.indymedia.org/view/Local/BrisbaneCrisisResolution

Disagreements are natural with such a large and diverse movement. Back in 2002 the global Indymedia network was awarded a $50,000 grant from the Ford Foundation in response to a proposal submitted by a few volunteers. What could have been a boon to the expanding network ended up spawning an international conflict. With no agreed process for reaching consensus on whether to accept the money or how to distribute it. The bitter arguments became too much for the network to bear and the grant was returned. A volunteer at the Urbana-Champagne IMC, said that the debate threatened to, "create fissures in the network that would take years to fix."

Without a doubt, the most infamous and embarrassing Indymedia squabble was the one that led to San Fransicio collective splitting up and forming two competing websites. The conflict provided much ammusment for the right wing trolls.  http://www.littlegreenfootballs.com/weblog/?entry=9565

Is the UK network now going through a similar incident, only time will tell. Thr arguments over the G8 debt represents just one of many disagreements driving a wedge into the fragile network. Other disagreements include the thorny question of how to deal with the unsustainable workload of keeping the newswire free from inappropriate content and what to do about the trolling of the comments section. With no network wide consensus some of the regional IMCs are talking about implementing their own solutions which some say are the start of a slippery slope towards a fractured network.

Pedro Heill


Comments

Display the following 22 comments

  1. Could see this coming a mile off — twilight
  2. Whats wrong with autonomy? — an individual
  3. perhaps — Krop
  4. A hoax — Steve
  5. One of Indymedia's biggest problems atm ...... — Woody
  6. Keep this off the newswire — x
  7. 2 Cents — Proof Of Effectiveness
  8. The voice of the bosses — lower ranks
  9. Delusions of Adequacy — Boab
  10. Proof — proofreader
  11. Proofreader! — Boab
  12. Spook? — Rob Ray
  13. Notes — London Activist
  14. Rob Ray — model
  15. the evil blair must be stopped — REX
  16. England is oppressive, evil, tyrannical, and must be defeated — emr
  17. Re: Spooks — Rob Ray
  18. idea — Unai
  19. Indymedia is Finito, Kapoot, dead! — Mrs annet wooverer
  20. understand this — emr
  21. It would be nice — commentator
  22. Yawn — resista

Links

Server Appeal Radio Page Video Page Indymedia Cinema Offline Newsheet