Skip to content or view mobile version

Home | Mobile | Editorial | Mission | Privacy | About | Contact | Help | Security | Support

A network of individuals, independent and alternative media activists and organisations, offering grassroots, non-corporate, non-commercial coverage of important social and political issues.

Did corruption kill the Nimrod 14?

R.A.McCartney | 21.05.2008 15:17 | Analysis | Anti-militarism | Technology

Former arms industry whistle-blower Rob McCartney believes the deaths of 14 service personnel in the 2006 Nimrod disaster could be due to fraud and corruption. He has written to the coroner conducting their inquest about this. The former head of BAe said the company regularly overcharged for changes to increase their profits. Such changes fatally delayed the replacement of the Nimrod MR2 by safer aircraft.

The inquest has heard that the Nimrod MR2 was “beyond its sell-by date” and that “shocking” corrosion led to frequent fuel leaks on such planes. The MOD's official inquiry concluded that the plane exploded because leaking fuel came into contact with a hot pipe. It also said that the age of the plane was a factor.

The Nimrod MR2 should have been replaced by the new Nimrod MRA4 at least three years before the Afghanistan disaster. Rob says “If that had happened, those 14 people would not have been killed”. British Aerospace (BAe, now BAE Systems) were given the contract for the MRA4 in 1996. It is ten years late because of repeated changes to the specification. Rob says he is suspicious because “People in the Defence Industry and the MOD have been taught for at least thirty years that the agreed specification should not be changed unless absolutely necessary. It is well known that it causes huge delays and cost escalation”.

“The importance of not changing the agreed specification was repeatedly hammered into me when I joined the industry” says Rob. He admits it is hard for people without his training and experience to understand this.

A modern military aircraft like the Nimrod MRA4 contains an enormous amount of complicated electronic equipment, including the aircraft controls, the cockpit displays, and the radar. The MRA4 reportedly has around 5.4 million lines of computer code. The software for these systems is developed using variations of the Waterfall method. Once the specification for the equipment has been agreed, the work involved in changing it grows exponentially as the project proceeds. Making a change near the end of the project can involve 200 times more work than including the same requirement in the original specification. This means that, in practise, the supposed advantage of any change is almost always outweighed by the huge delay and increased cost.

Changing the hardware design is even more disastrous than changing the software.

“Everybody knows this” says Rob, “so how could they allow changes to the specification which doubled the price to around £4 billion, and delayed the introduction of the MRA4 by ten years?”

Rob says some companies deliberately invent excuses to change the specification and massively overcharge. “On one project they even put in requirements which their own technical experts told them were impossible”. In January 2004 Sir Raymond Lygo told the BBC that when he was head of British Aerospace, they regularly put in low bids for contracts with the intention of using changes to increase prices and profits. The following month the Public Accounts Committee asked Sir Kevin Tebbit, the top MOD civil servant, how he could be sure this was not still happening. He tried to blame the problem on Cost Plus contracts.

In March 1987 Dale Campbell-Savours MP, a Labour member of the Public Accounts Committee, accused Marconi of making misleading changes requests on the 1985 BATES contract in order to push up the price. Labour Minister Lord Gilbert admitted in 1997 that this was not a Cost Plus contract, but a Firm Price one, the strictest type of contract the MOD can award. Rob has previously published evidence proving that Lord Gilbert and two Tory ministers all lied to cover up the fact that there had been a huge increase in the price due to changes.

Rob reported several frauds to the Ministry of Defence Police in June 2000. This included the alleged fraud on BATES. Some of the minor allegations received media coverage in The Observer, The Sunday Times and on BBC radio. However, Rob says the enquiry was “worse than the Deepcut Barracks deaths enquiries”. Rob lived close to Deepcut at the time of the enquiries, and at one time used to drive past the Barracks every day on his way to and from work.

According to Rob, the MOD Police investigating his allegations didn't even pretend to be impartial. They accepted several blatant lies by MOD civil servants about different frauds. The Royal Military Police investigating the Deepcut deaths accepted that Private Geoff Gray committed suicide by shooting himself in the head twice, although independent experts said this was impossible. The MOD Police accepted that “The price which was paid for the BATES project was the price which was originally agreed”, although the price was £100 million when the contract was awarded in April 1985, and over £300 million when it was accepted in 1993.

Firm Price contracts only allow for price increases due to inflation or changes to the specification. Under the 1985 contract, BATES should have been delivered by November 1987, and all further costs should have been paid by Marconi. The MOD told the National Audit Office that BATES required three years of extra work due to “Unforeseen Technical Problems”. “I had a reputation for highlighting problems on that project”, says Rob “and I never heard of any major unforeseen technical problems”.

Rob has declined to talk to Charles Haddon-Cave QC, who is conducting the ‘Nimrod Review’ on behalf of the Secretary of State for Defence. “For decades MOD civil servants and government ministers from both parties have been protecting fraud on MOD contracts” he says. “Any enquiry which is influenced by the MOD cannot be trusted”.

© Copyright R.A.McCartney

Cumulative index of Indymedia articles by R.A.McCartney (most recent first)

15.04.2008 Anti-corruption chiefs 'protect UK arms fraud & corruption'
 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2008/04/396660.html

06.01.2008 Max Hastings lies about corruption
 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2008/01/388887.html

17.12.2007 Major Corruption
 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2007/12/388046.html

10.12.2007 Arbuthnot backs arms industry campaign
 https://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2007/12/387431.html

25.11.2007 Ex-Defence Chiefs paid by arms industry
 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2007/11/386546.html

05.11.2007 Channel 4 Dispatches plays safe on corruption
 https://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2007/11/385134.html

02.10.2007 Thatcher gave Pergau Dam arms company “unjustifiable” £300m contract
 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2007/10/382700.html

09.09.2007 'Lies' by Transparency International 'protect UK corruption'
 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2007/09/380641.html

30.04.2007 TI re-examine UK fraud & corruption report
 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2007/04/369088.html

R.A.McCartney

Upcoming Coverage
View and post events
Upcoming Events UK
24th October, London: 2015 London Anarchist Bookfair
2nd - 8th November: Wrexham, Wales, UK & Everywhere: Week of Action Against the North Wales Prison & the Prison Industrial Complex. Cymraeg: Wythnos o Weithredu yn Erbyn Carchar Gogledd Cymru

Ongoing UK
Every Tuesday 6pm-8pm, Yorkshire: Demo/vigil at NSA/NRO Menwith Hill US Spy Base More info: CAAB.

Every Tuesday, UK & worldwide: Counter Terror Tuesdays. Call the US Embassy nearest to you to protest Obama's Terror Tuesdays. More info here

Every day, London: Vigil for Julian Assange outside Ecuadorian Embassy

Parliament Sq Protest: see topic page
Ongoing Global
Rossport, Ireland: see topic page
Israel-Palestine: Israel Indymedia | Palestine Indymedia
Oaxaca: Chiapas Indymedia
Regions
All Regions
Birmingham
Cambridge
Liverpool
London
Oxford
Sheffield
South Coast
Wales
World
Other Local IMCs
Bristol/South West
Nottingham
Scotland
Social Media
You can follow @ukindymedia on indy.im and Twitter. We are working on a Twitter policy. We do not use Facebook, and advise you not to either.
Support Us
We need help paying the bills for hosting this site, please consider supporting us financially.
Other Media Projects
Schnews
Dissident Island Radio
Corporate Watch
Media Lens
VisionOnTV
Earth First! Action Update
Earth First! Action Reports
Topics
All Topics
Afghanistan
Analysis
Animal Liberation
Anti-Nuclear
Anti-militarism
Anti-racism
Bio-technology
Climate Chaos
Culture
Ecology
Education
Energy Crisis
Fracking
Free Spaces
Gender
Globalisation
Health
History
Indymedia
Iraq
Migration
Ocean Defence
Other Press
Palestine
Policing
Public sector cuts
Repression
Social Struggles
Technology
Terror War
Workers' Movements
Zapatista
Major Reports
NATO 2014
G8 2013
Workfare
2011 Census Resistance
Occupy Everywhere
August Riots
Dale Farm
J30 Strike
Flotilla to Gaza
Mayday 2010
Tar Sands
G20 London Summit
University Occupations for Gaza
Guantanamo
Indymedia Server Seizure
COP15 Climate Summit 2009
Carmel Agrexco
G8 Japan 2008
SHAC
Stop Sequani
Stop RWB
Climate Camp 2008
Oaxaca Uprising
Rossport Solidarity
Smash EDO
SOCPA
Past Major Reports
Encrypted Page
You are viewing this page using an encrypted connection. If you bookmark this page or send its address in an email you might want to use the un-encrypted address of this page.
If you recieved a warning about an untrusted root certificate please install the CAcert root certificate, for more information see the security page.

Global IMC Network


www.indymedia.org

Projects
print
radio
satellite tv
video

Africa

Europe
antwerpen
armenia
athens
austria
barcelona
belarus
belgium
belgrade
brussels
bulgaria
calabria
croatia
cyprus
emilia-romagna
estrecho / madiaq
galiza
germany
grenoble
hungary
ireland
istanbul
italy
la plana
liege
liguria
lille
linksunten
lombardia
madrid
malta
marseille
nantes
napoli
netherlands
northern england
nottingham imc
paris/île-de-france
patras
piemonte
poland
portugal
roma
romania
russia
sardegna
scotland
sverige
switzerland
torun
toscana
ukraine
united kingdom
valencia

Latin America
argentina
bolivia
chiapas
chile
chile sur
cmi brasil
cmi sucre
colombia
ecuador
mexico
peru
puerto rico
qollasuyu
rosario
santiago
tijuana
uruguay
valparaiso
venezuela

Oceania
aotearoa
brisbane
burma
darwin
jakarta
manila
melbourne
perth
qc
sydney

South Asia
india


United States
arizona
arkansas
asheville
atlanta
Austin
binghamton
boston
buffalo
chicago
cleveland
colorado
columbus
dc
hawaii
houston
hudson mohawk
kansas city
la
madison
maine
miami
michigan
milwaukee
minneapolis/st. paul
new hampshire
new jersey
new mexico
new orleans
north carolina
north texas
nyc
oklahoma
philadelphia
pittsburgh
portland
richmond
rochester
rogue valley
saint louis
san diego
san francisco
san francisco bay area
santa barbara
santa cruz, ca
sarasota
seattle
tampa bay
united states
urbana-champaign
vermont
western mass
worcester

West Asia
Armenia
Beirut
Israel
Palestine

Topics
biotech

Process
fbi/legal updates
mailing lists
process & imc docs
tech