info-shifter | 29.10.2001 12:51
Media witchhunt Australian boxer for opposing US war (english)
by Richard Philips 10:20pm Sun Oct 28 '01 (Modified on 3:46am Mon Oct 29 '01)
Another story on censorship and spin by corporate media.
Media witchhunt Australian boxer for opposing US war
By Richard Phillips
29 October 2001
The treatment meted out in the media to Australian boxer Anthony Mundine over the past week reveals that the political establishment cannot tolerate any criticism of the US-led war in Afghanistan. In the matter of a day, he was transformed from a “role model” for young Australians to persona non grata and subjected to crude insults, political bullying and threats to his career.
Twenty-six-year-old Mundine, a talented Aboriginal sportsman, is the current International Boxing Federation (IBF) Pan-Pacific super-middle weight champion and in training for a world title fight in Germany on December 1. Before becoming a professional boxer in 2000 he was a first-class rugby league football player.
Last Monday, the day after he had successfully defended his IBF title with a knockout victory, Mundine was hailed as boxing’s “man of the moment”. Appearing on Channel Nine’s Today program, Mundine was asked what he thought about the war against Afghanistan. After explaining that he opposed the participation of Australian troops, Mundine said: “It’s not about terrorism, it’s about fighting for God’s laws, and America has brought it upon themselves [for] what they’ve done in the history of time.”
The interview was suddenly cut—the network blamed technical difficulties—and all hell broke lose in newsrooms across the country. The media seized on Mundine’s rather confused comments, and the fact that he had converted to Islam in 1998, to claim that he supported the September 11 terrorist attacks on the US and had blamed the victims for their own deaths.
Talkback radio announcers began denouncing him as an “extremist,” unpatriotic and a supporter of the Taliban and Osama bin Laden. Labor Party leader Kim Beazley and a string of state and federal politicians criticised him and several local Islamic leaders claimed he had given Muslims a bad name.
Significantly, in light of the media reaction, Channel Nine later revealed that the public response to Mundine’s comments was far from being all negative. The network’s switchboard had been swamped by phone calls, half of them from viewers accusing station management of censoring the sports star because he had opposed the war.
Mundine was immediately contacted by the Foxtel cable television network, his principal financial backer and the pay-per-view channel with exclusive rights to the boxer’s fights. Foxtel television chief Brian Walsh told the boxer in no uncertain terms that his personal life and sporting career would be destroyed unless he made a public apology.
Later that night on Channel Nine’s Ray Martin Show, Mundine categorically condemned the September 11 attacks and apologised for any grief he may have caused by his previous comments. But the boxer also restated his opposition to the war. “I am against sending our soldiers over there. War is not the answer,” he firmly told Martin. “There is going to be more killings, there is going to be more body bags, and there is going to be more grief and sorrow, not just here but around the world.”
The anti-Mundine campaign continued unabated the next day. IBF ratings chairman Joe Dwyer told the press that Mundine’s comments had “killed his career” and he should “stay out of America”. Local and US sporting officials denounced Mundine and US cable television networks—HBO and Showtime—said he was now “too hot to handle.” By Thursday, the World Boxing Council announced that it had cancelled Mundine’s international ranking indefinitely, ruling out his chances of fighting in the US.
Mundine was lambasted in virtually every newspaper in the country. Writing for the Age newspaper in Melbourne, Greg Baume was typical. Baume ignored the political questions raised by Mundine’s remarks and simply hurled abuse at the boxer, denouncing him as “thick” and an idiot. Tuesday’s edition of the Rupert Murdoch-owned Sydney Daily Telegraph went into overdrive with an editorial, three major comments, three news articles and an op-ed cartoon—all attacking him. The editorial demanded the boxer “explain the reason for his views and apologise for them”.
In a piece entitled “Punch drunk on perversity,” the Daily Telegraph’s columnist Piers Akerman warned Mundine that if wanted to “retain his right” to comment from “the safety and security of our democracy” then “he should support the US.” Akerman seemed oblivious to the obvious question: what sort of “democracy” is it when only those who support the US-led war and the powers-that-be have the right to free speech?
In reality, the war has nothing to do with defending democracy in Afghanistan, the US or Australia, where basic democratic rights are increasingly under attack. The crude attempts to silence Mundine indicate a nervousness in official circles that support for the war is not as solid as the media would have it appear. The fear is that any criticism of the war—by Mundine or anyone else—will become a focus for wider opposition.
Commentator Miranda Devine revealed these concerns in the Sydney Morning Herald, a newspaper that postures as a “liberal” alternative to its Murdoch-owned rivals. The main issue was not Mundine, Devine suggested, but “countless left-leaning Western commentators,” whom she claimed supported the Taliban. Devine singled out Australian journalists Philip Adams, Bob Ellis and John Pilger, as well as Susan Sontag and Edward Said in the US, describing them as “traitorous” and said they functioned as “handmaidens of Osama bin Laden”.
The message is clear: any criticism of the war, no matter how timid or confused, has to be silenced.
add your own comments
In exalted company (english)
by Ravi 10:45pm Sun Oct 28 '01
At least Anthony Mundine is in exalted company. So was Muhammad Ali excoriated for
opposing the disgraceful war on Vietnam.
3 thoughts on boxing (english)
by Pontius warthog 2:39am Mon Oct 29 '01
Psyching up;Ali freaked out sonny liston by acting crazy.
[USAma could threaten to nuke saudi oil fields]
Rope a dope;USAma seems to have this down cold,Also,he probably noticed the last heavyweight fights disparity in fighters sizes,"no lucky punch,indeed'
3)Very few get this right...knowing when to retire.A tough one.In the clearing stands a boxer...
Way to go Mundine! (english)
by Freedom Fighters 3:46am Mon Oct 29 '01
You have your heart in the right place. And, what is this; “explain the reason for his views and apologise for them”? Voicing ones own views and thoughts on matters is an integral part of any "sound" democracy. Is Sydney Daily Telegraph implying that the Australian people should not be allowed to speak their minds on important matters but only accept what they are being force fed with? Now "that" sounds like a "very" dangerous path...