Life on Dubya’s Animal Farm: Orwell and the Stockton Protest (USA)
Dwayne Eutsey | 27.08.2002 13:27
The parallels between 2002 and 1984 are obvious. However, as I listened to news reports of the anti-Bush protest in Stockton, California on Friday, the book that came to mind was Orwell’s other classic, Animal Farm.
Many disturbing comparisons have been drawn between the totalitarian society George Orwell describes in 1984 and George Bush’s Amurika.
The similarities are easy to see, even if you’ve only read the Cliff’s Notes version of Orwell’s book: Citizens are encouraged to spy on one another, there’s endless war with ever-changing enemies, the media herald Big Dubya as the greatest leader in human history (while promptly dispatching his many embarrassing gaffes down the memory hole), and, as we’ve seen in Portland recently, dissent is coldly quashed with police-state tactics.
The parallels between 2002 and 1984 are obvious. However, as I listened to news reports of the anti-Bush protest in Stockton, California on Friday, the book that came to mind was Orwell’s other classic, Animal Farm.
With its obvious allusions to Soviet Russia, this dark satire about animals taking over and running a farm isn’t usually associated with the cabal of rightwingers currently controlling this country in the same way 1984 is. But aside from the striking correlations between members of the Bush regime and the avaricious pigs that run Animal Farm (Ari Fliescher and Squealer the pig propagandist could easily have been separated at birth), what happened in Stockton is something straight out of Orwell’s barnyard.
If you didn’t hear about the protest (and chances are you didn’t if you get your news from corporate media), here’s what happened:
Bush came to Stockton on yet another of his Republican fund-raising appearances (if he put the same energy into winning his war on terrorism as he does in raising money for his GOP cronies, the terrorists would be vanquished by now). According to reports on KPFA FM and Indymedia (LINK TO
http://sf.indymedia.org/news/2002/08/142871.php), up to 1,000 anti-Bush activists showed up, some of them bussed in from the northern California area. They came to demonstrate opposition to the impending war with Iraq, among other issues.
Although a number of Bush supporters were also bussed to the event from the surrounding area, there were still many seats available in the auditorium where Bush was scheduled to speak. So the GOP, in its desperation to pack the house with supporters to cheer on their made-for-TV president, gave away tickets to anyone who wanted them—including, without realizing it, a few protesters.
Taking advantage of their good fortune, these brave Americans did what most of us are no longer allowed to do anymore: they openly voiced their dissent right in front of the media and before the Charlatan-in-Chief himself. Their act of defiance is a true blow for democracy in these repressive times when reasonable anti-war viewpoints are shut out of the mainstream media, and when citizens who peacefully exercise their right to protest are either confined in “First Amendment Zones” or are pepper-sprayed, beaten, and shot with rubber bullets by police.
Their bold action of resistance kind of reminded me for a moment that we’re supposed to be living in a free society. But what happened next at the protest brought me back to the reality of what we have actually become: bit players in George Bush’s production of Animal Farm.
In Orwell’s book, if anyone questioned Napoleon, the lead pig on the farm, “the sheep were sure to silence him with a tremendous bleating of ‘Four legs good, two legs bad!’” The bleating would continue until all questions were forgotten or dissenters were too intimidated to raise them again. Similarly, the citizens in the auditorium who dared question the sanity of AWOL Bush’s disastrous plans to invade Iraq were drowned out by the GOP sheep obediently bleating “USA! USA! USA!”
Like dogs trained to sniff out and attack illegal substances, the police dragged the protesters out of the auditorium and placed them under arrest. As the braying continued thundering throughout the auditorium, a new order was restored.
To their credit, some corporate media have reported the incident. The brief reports I’ve seen, though, focused mostly on the deafening chants and completely ignored what the protesters were saying along with the many anti-Bush demonstrators who were gathered outside.
But this kind of distortion of reality shouldn’t surprise us any more, should it? I mean, after all, we should know by now that in George Bush’s Amurika, as in George Orwell’s Animal Farm, all of us animals are created equal. But some animals here are more equal than others.
###
The similarities are easy to see, even if you’ve only read the Cliff’s Notes version of Orwell’s book: Citizens are encouraged to spy on one another, there’s endless war with ever-changing enemies, the media herald Big Dubya as the greatest leader in human history (while promptly dispatching his many embarrassing gaffes down the memory hole), and, as we’ve seen in Portland recently, dissent is coldly quashed with police-state tactics.
The parallels between 2002 and 1984 are obvious. However, as I listened to news reports of the anti-Bush protest in Stockton, California on Friday, the book that came to mind was Orwell’s other classic, Animal Farm.
With its obvious allusions to Soviet Russia, this dark satire about animals taking over and running a farm isn’t usually associated with the cabal of rightwingers currently controlling this country in the same way 1984 is. But aside from the striking correlations between members of the Bush regime and the avaricious pigs that run Animal Farm (Ari Fliescher and Squealer the pig propagandist could easily have been separated at birth), what happened in Stockton is something straight out of Orwell’s barnyard.
If you didn’t hear about the protest (and chances are you didn’t if you get your news from corporate media), here’s what happened:
Bush came to Stockton on yet another of his Republican fund-raising appearances (if he put the same energy into winning his war on terrorism as he does in raising money for his GOP cronies, the terrorists would be vanquished by now). According to reports on KPFA FM and Indymedia (LINK TO
http://sf.indymedia.org/news/2002/08/142871.php), up to 1,000 anti-Bush activists showed up, some of them bussed in from the northern California area. They came to demonstrate opposition to the impending war with Iraq, among other issues. Although a number of Bush supporters were also bussed to the event from the surrounding area, there were still many seats available in the auditorium where Bush was scheduled to speak. So the GOP, in its desperation to pack the house with supporters to cheer on their made-for-TV president, gave away tickets to anyone who wanted them—including, without realizing it, a few protesters.
Taking advantage of their good fortune, these brave Americans did what most of us are no longer allowed to do anymore: they openly voiced their dissent right in front of the media and before the Charlatan-in-Chief himself. Their act of defiance is a true blow for democracy in these repressive times when reasonable anti-war viewpoints are shut out of the mainstream media, and when citizens who peacefully exercise their right to protest are either confined in “First Amendment Zones” or are pepper-sprayed, beaten, and shot with rubber bullets by police.
Their bold action of resistance kind of reminded me for a moment that we’re supposed to be living in a free society. But what happened next at the protest brought me back to the reality of what we have actually become: bit players in George Bush’s production of Animal Farm.
In Orwell’s book, if anyone questioned Napoleon, the lead pig on the farm, “the sheep were sure to silence him with a tremendous bleating of ‘Four legs good, two legs bad!’” The bleating would continue until all questions were forgotten or dissenters were too intimidated to raise them again. Similarly, the citizens in the auditorium who dared question the sanity of AWOL Bush’s disastrous plans to invade Iraq were drowned out by the GOP sheep obediently bleating “USA! USA! USA!”
Like dogs trained to sniff out and attack illegal substances, the police dragged the protesters out of the auditorium and placed them under arrest. As the braying continued thundering throughout the auditorium, a new order was restored.
To their credit, some corporate media have reported the incident. The brief reports I’ve seen, though, focused mostly on the deafening chants and completely ignored what the protesters were saying along with the many anti-Bush demonstrators who were gathered outside.
But this kind of distortion of reality shouldn’t surprise us any more, should it? I mean, after all, we should know by now that in George Bush’s Amurika, as in George Orwell’s Animal Farm, all of us animals are created equal. But some animals here are more equal than others.
###
Dwayne Eutsey
