Apartheid Israel bans its Arab citizens from internal flights
Avalon | 14.06.2006 10:45 | Repression | Social Struggles
People who argue that Israel is an apartheid state say that the system of apartheid is much more subtle than the old South African model of "whites only" beach signs. But sometimes it really is just like South Africa...
Probe: Flights from north to central Israel are 'Jews only'
By Zohar Blumenkrantz, Haaretz Correspondent
An investigation by Haaretz has revealed that there is a Jewish passengers only policy on flights from Rosh Pina and Kiryat Shmona in the north, to Tel Aviv in the center of the country.
The Transportation Ministry, acting on instruction from the Shin Bet security service, decided that Arabs would not be allowed on the flights following a financial dispute that prevented the use of luggage scanning machines in airports in the north.
Teh flights from the north to the center of the country are operated by Tamir Flights, which won a Transportation Ministry tender in March. To operate the flights, the company bought a scanning machine, to inspect passengers' suitcases and carry-on items.
The machine was to have been placed at the new terminal in Kiryat Shmona, but a difference of opinion over the use of the terminal has ensued between Tamir Flights, the Transportation and Industry and Trade Ministries, as well as the Kiryat Shmona municipality.
In April, the Industry and Trade stopped funding providing the NIS 30,000 monthly cost for security for the building, saying, "The new operator must bear responsibility for securing both the the equipment and the building." As a result, the necessary security checks are not conducted, and non-Jewish passengers are not allowed to board flights.
Udi Tamir, one of Tamir Flight's owners, confirmed Tuesday that non-Jews are not permitted on flights, saying he cannot allow all passengers on flights, because there is no scanning machine at the airport in Kiryat Shmona. Tamir added that he is operating according to security forces' instructions.
According to the Transportation Ministry, "This is not discrimination, but a technical malfunction. We are trying to find an immediate solution that will permit all of the country's citizens to fly from northern Israel, without restrictions."
By Zohar Blumenkrantz, Haaretz Correspondent
An investigation by Haaretz has revealed that there is a Jewish passengers only policy on flights from Rosh Pina and Kiryat Shmona in the north, to Tel Aviv in the center of the country.
The Transportation Ministry, acting on instruction from the Shin Bet security service, decided that Arabs would not be allowed on the flights following a financial dispute that prevented the use of luggage scanning machines in airports in the north.
Teh flights from the north to the center of the country are operated by Tamir Flights, which won a Transportation Ministry tender in March. To operate the flights, the company bought a scanning machine, to inspect passengers' suitcases and carry-on items.
The machine was to have been placed at the new terminal in Kiryat Shmona, but a difference of opinion over the use of the terminal has ensued between Tamir Flights, the Transportation and Industry and Trade Ministries, as well as the Kiryat Shmona municipality.
In April, the Industry and Trade stopped funding providing the NIS 30,000 monthly cost for security for the building, saying, "The new operator must bear responsibility for securing both the the equipment and the building." As a result, the necessary security checks are not conducted, and non-Jewish passengers are not allowed to board flights.
Udi Tamir, one of Tamir Flight's owners, confirmed Tuesday that non-Jews are not permitted on flights, saying he cannot allow all passengers on flights, because there is no scanning machine at the airport in Kiryat Shmona. Tamir added that he is operating according to security forces' instructions.
According to the Transportation Ministry, "This is not discrimination, but a technical malfunction. We are trying to find an immediate solution that will permit all of the country's citizens to fly from northern Israel, without restrictions."
Avalon
Comments
Hide the following 3 comments
You contradict yourself
14.06.2006 11:34
Now, either it's apartheid, i.e. permanent policy of the Israeli government, or a technical malfunction.
Seeing as it's a technical malfunction, and they hope to permit all (note the word ALL) the country's citizens to fly, this cannot by any stretch of the imagination (unless you're being deliberately obtuse to make a false poi) be called apartheid policy.
Stop looking for trouble where there isn't any. There's enough of the real stuff around.
ank
ank - point well missed
14.06.2006 16:15
D'oh
Melson Nandela
Response to #1
15.06.2006 13:18
How about if I rephrase the article...
"A spokesman for London Underground said that due to a financial dispute, video cameras are not able to be installed at tube stations throughout the capital. Therefore, London Underground has decided that black people will not be able to use the tube. Until the problem is rectified only whites will be allowed on. A Downing Street spokesman said, "This is not discrimination, but a technical malfunction. We are trying to find an immediate solution that will permit all of the capital's citizens to travel around London, without restrictions.""
Would that be acceptable to you as well?
Avalon